Devising a blueprint to fund optical science

July 1, 1995
How can optical science and engineering help improve US society? What are the "grand challenges" that optical science should tackle in the coming decades? And what roles should government, industry, and academia play in meeting those challenges?

How can optical science and engineering help improve US society? What are the "grand challenges" that optical science should tackle in the coming decades? And what roles should government, industry, and academia play in meeting those challenges?

These sweeping questions are all part of a new study launched recently by the National Research Council (NRC) of the National Academy of Sciences. With financial support from several US government agencies, the new NRC study has the overall goal of assessing the field of optical science and engineering and recommending a blueprint for how it should develop in the future.

The study could profoundly influence how the US government spends its research funds on optical sciences, helping federal agencies set priorities for the projects that they will support financially, says Tom McIlrath of the National Science Foundation (NSF). The "grand challenges" also could help researchers pick directions for their own research, he says.

The study is being conducted by the NRCs newly formed Committee on Optical Science and Engineering. The panel is chaired by Charles Shank, director of the US Energy Departments Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory (Berkeley, CA). Vice chair is Aram Mooradian of Micracor (Acton, MA).

The COSE report is due in 1997. To prepare the report, the committee plans to hold a series of hearings at which invited experts will address five broad topics: manufacturing; information technology; optics in health care and life sciences; energy, space and environment; and research, development, engineering, education and training. The expert witnesses will be selected from both industry and academia to give a broad and deep view of the needs and promise of optical science and engineering, Mooradian said during the CLEO/QELS 95 meeting in Baltimore, MD.

A key challenge facing the COSE panel is documenting the economic impact of optical science and engineering, Mooradian said. If optical science doesnt produce many jobs or other economic benefits, then there is little argument for spending more federal money in the field, he said.

Tracking technology transfer

Initially, the study panel will try to determine exactly how much money is spent in the USA on development of optical and photonic technology, Mooradian said. Next, the committee will try to determine the extent to which photonic technologies are used in other technologies such as in manufacturing, an application of optical technology that "enables massive markets," Mooradian said. Overall, the COSE panel wants to reconstruct how new technologies developed in academia find their way into industry, Mooradian said.

The panel is keenly interested in getting a wide range of views from scientists and engineers in lasers, photonics and other optical fieldsboth in academia and industry. The committee is looking for suggestions for witnesses to testify at its hearings as well as feedback regarding whether it has covered all important areas. "Without the right areas to look at and without the right people, the report will just sit on a shelf, and we dont want that," Mooradian said.

The COSE study would seem to cover ground that, in part, has already been explored by the Optoelectronics Development Industry Association, which has been drafting technology roadmaps for the industry. Arpad Bergh, executive director of OIDA, says the groups roadmaps tend to focus on three-year horizons. The COSE study likely will take a much longer view and include areas not covered by OIDA roadmaps, such as materials and manufacturing infrastructure. OIDA has offered to supply its studies to COSE, but, as of early June, a mechanism for doing that hadnt been decided, Bergh says.

NSF proposal

The COSE study is being launched a year after the National Science Foundation convened a panel of optical scientists for a brainstorming session to propose changes in the way the NSF provides support for optical science and engineering. That panel of scientists suggested that the NSF create an agency-wide interdisciplinary program in optical sciences that would encourage researchers to pursue cutting-edge projects in optical science and engineering. NSF officials said at CLEO/QELS 95 that those recommendations generally were well received at NSF, but agency officials are still mulling over the feasibility of creating such an interdisciplinary program. "We hope that we will see our way clear to being able to make an effort in this area," says the NSFs Larry Goldberg.

At CLEO/QELS 95, Goldberg said that NSF doesnt expect to get any new money for Congress to launch an interdisciplinary program in optical sciences. That means that the funds to pay for such a program would have to be diverted from other NSF projects. "It is not going to be based on new funds," Goldberg said.

And there may not be that much money available to scavenge to start a new program. After years of increases for NSF, many Republicans would like to see the foundations budget level off or decline. The hesitancy of NSF officials to commit to the new program is directly due to the uncertainty that looms over the NSFs budget. "We all look through the same murky glass," Goldberg said.

About the Author

Vincent Kiernan | Washington Editor

Vincent Kiernan was Washington Editor for Laser Focus World.

Sponsored Recommendations

Brain Computer Interface (BCI) electrode manufacturing

Jan. 31, 2025
Learn how an industry-leading Brain Computer Interface Electrode (BCI) manufacturer used precision laser micromachining to produce high-density neural microelectrode arrays.

Electro-Optic Sensor and System Performance Verification with Motion Systems

Jan. 31, 2025
To learn how to use motion control equipment for electro-optic sensor testing, click here to read our whitepaper!

How nanopositioning helped achieve fusion ignition

Jan. 31, 2025
In December 2022, the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory's National Ignition Facility (NIF) achieved fusion ignition. Learn how Aerotech nanopositioning contributed to this...

Nanometer Scale Industrial Automation for Optical Device Manufacturing

Jan. 31, 2025
In optical device manufacturing, choosing automation technologies at the R&D level that are also suitable for production environments is critical to bringing new devices to market...

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Laser Focus World, create an account today!