LETTERS: A response to 'Laser pulse filaments produce Hawking radiation'

I read the news item in Laser Focus World [p. 18, November 2010] of the femtosecond news section, entitled "Laser pulse filaments produce Hawking radiation."

Jan 1st, 2011
46484

Dear Steve:
I read the news item in Laser Focus World [p. 18, November 2010] of the femtosecond news section, entitled "Laser pulse filaments produce Hawking radiation."

I am sorry to say the optical radiation observed by researchers at Università degli Studi di Milano, INFN sezione di Milano, Università dell'Insubria, and Università di Milano-Bicocca in Italy and Heriot-Watt University in Edinburgh, Scotland using a fs/ps laser pulse to create filaments in glass and observed at 90° to the laser path, [which is] attributed to Hawking radiation is wrong. They stated that "...self phase modulation and four wave mixing (observed previously in glass in three seminal papers by Albano and Shapiro, PRL 24,592,584,1219(1970) does not occur at 90 deg..." This is true; however, the forward supercontinuum radiation can scatter by elastic light scattering at 90° from Rayleigh, Brillouin, and/or depolarizer wing scattering. This note questions the origin to Hawking radiation, and recent observation attributes to light scattering from forward supercontinuum light. See photo enclosed of SC.

Dr. Robert R. Alfano
Distinguished Professor, Department of Physics; Director, Institute for Ultrafast Spectroscopy and Lasers, The City College of New York; e-mail: [email protected];www1.ccny.cuny.edu/ci/iusl

More Laser Focus World Current Issue Articles
More Laser Focus World Archives Issue Articles

More in Research
Femtosecond Applications Benefit from Ytterbium Amplifiers
Sponsored
Femtosecond Applications Benefit from Ytterbium Amplifiers

Learn how Monaco extends capabilities and enables new experiments in diverse fields such as THz microscopy, metal texturing, and multiphoton imaging.

Aug 28th, 2019
FIGURE 1. The rubidium titanyl phosphate (RTP) Q-switch is assembled in a thermally compensated double-crystal configuration in which two matched crystals are placed in line with the propagation axis (x or y) with one crystal rotated by 90° with respect to the other.
Test & Measurement
Optical Materials: RTP optical crystal helps boost performance of LIGO

Upgrading the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory (LIGO) included the addition of a rubidium titanyl phosphate (RTP) Q-switch to handle high optical powers.

Sep 17th, 2019
Dr. Constantin Häfner.
Lasers & Sources
Constantin Häfner named new director of Fraunhofer Institute for Laser Technology ILT

Effective November 2019, laser physicist Dr. Constantin Häfner will be taking on the Directorship of Fraunhofer ILT in Aachen, Germany. He is currently Program Director for Advanced Photon Technologies at LLNL in the U.S.

John Wallace
Sep 16th, 2019
John Lewis 720
Commentary
Lasers for lidar and more

Editor in chief John Lewis introduces Laser Focus World’s August 2019 issue, which includes trends in photonics technologies, applications, and markets.

John Lewis
Aug 13th, 2019
1908 Lfw Nb F3
Optics
Large-field cryogenic objective mirror has nearly diffraction-limited performance

Designed for use while being cooled by liquid helium, a cryogenic objective mirror with an aspherical surface has a NA of 0.93 and a field radius of 36 µm, large enough to image mammalian cells.

John Wallace
Aug 13th, 2019
Shown are tuning curves for three quantum dots positioned on the waveguide at the locations shown in the inset, to achieve identical emission (a). High-resolution Fabry-Perot interferometer measurements show all three quantum dots simultaneously from an output coupler with identical emission wavelength (b).
Lasers & Sources
Quantum Sources: Squeezed quantum dots create coherent streams of quantum-ready photons

By squeezing quantum dots using unique semiconductor-based processes, coherent single photons are generated that can be used for on-chip quantum photonics that demand identical photons from multiple integrated sources.

Gail Overton
Aug 13th, 2019
FIGURE 1. In the scalable setting of a spatial photonic Ising machine, binary spins are encoded in the phase of a laser beam (green) by spatial modulation. Tailoring of the beam’s amplitude fixes spin-spin interaction. To find the ground-state spin configuration, the machine recurrently evolves according to a feedback signal from the camera plane. By design, maximizing the intensity in a target region (blue square) corresponds to a spin state with minimum energy.
Software
Photonics Modeling: Optical Ising machines solve complex engineering, science, and even business problems

Researchers have built the largest photonic Ising machine to date—an optical processor for solving difficult optimization problems by modeling interacting spins via a spatially varying light field.

Aug 13th, 2019
To create a gold grating on a nanowire array (a), the nanowires themselves (vertical projections) were used as shadow masks by depositing the gold at an angle to the surface, resulting in undeposited areas (dark regions). Future nanowire-based separate absorption and multiplication avalanche photodiodes (SAM-APDs) will have faceted nanowires to help relieve lattice-mismatch strain (b).
Detectors & Imaging
Short- and mid-wavelength infrared nanowire photodiodes are uncooled

Nanowires of InAs and InAsSb on an indium phosphide substrate form room-temperature SWIR or MWIR photodiodes suitable for focal-plane arrays.

John Wallace
Jul 1st, 2019
1907 Lfw09 12 Nb 4
Optics
Metasurface lens on diamond single-photon quantum source efficiently collects photons

A nitrogen-vacancy (NV) diamond produces single photons; a metalens etched into its surface collects them, no microscope needed.

John Wallace
Jul 1st, 2019
Test & Measurement
On-chip laser-based quantum device generates true random numbers

A photonic integrated circuit containing two laser diodes whose outputs are interfered and measured produces truly random numbers at gigahertz rates.

John Wallace
Jul 1st, 2019