Laser/optics medical patients wooed by discounts

Aug. 15, 2008
NEW YORK, NY—A June 26th article in The New York Times reported that, while physician associations generally frown upon remuneration of patients to help promote medical services, many cosmetic surgeons now openly offer “thank you” rebates and discounts to patients who post videos of their operations or are willing to be taped enthusing about the capabilities of their physician.

NEW YORK, NY—A June 26th article in The New York Times reported that, while physician associations generally frown upon remuneration of patients to help promote medical services, many cosmetic surgeons now openly offer “thank you” rebates and discounts to patients who post videos of their operations or are willing to be taped enthusing about the capabilities of their physician.

As an example, the article cited Dr. Emil Chynn of New York’s Park Avenue Laser, who has provided laser assisted sub-epithelial keratomileusis (LASEK) patients with DVDs of their surgeries in hopes that they will post the ten-minute videos on YouTube, along with an endorsement and a link to Chynn’s Web site. As an incentive, Dr. Chynn offers a free Botox injection worth $400 or a $100 discount on the LASEK operation.

The increasingly common practice has raised concerns among medical ethicists and consumer advocates, the article said. Videos—which usually do not disclose the fact that the endorsement is paid—can either be home-grown or produced by marketing companies offering package deals.

Along similar lines, STAAR Surgical Company, maker of the Visian ICL (Implantable Collamer Lens), has announced plans for a consumer awareness internet campaign based on surgeons’ practices. According to the company’s press announcement, “Prospective Visian ICL patients will be invited to submit a one-minute video on why they opted for Visian versus other options, potentially including LASIK, earning them the possibility of winning a no-charge procedure.”

STAAR said that web sites for the campaign were being developed for leading Visian ICL physicians around the country and that local contests would begin in July 2008. “Finalists from local practices will be entered in a national internet-based contest in which the winning submission will be selected based on the most votes from site visitors,” the news release said.

Whether these practices are acceptable depends on who you ask. Certainly the post-surgery endorsements carry more weight than the prospective customer ones, meaning more potential trouble. The New York Times article notes that in one case, a dissatisfied patient (who asked to remain anonymous) posted his video and received the rebate before he realized his results were disappointing. The article quotes the patient as saying, “Regardless of whether I’m happy—that’s not going to stop me from posting. It’s money in my pocket.”

The New York Times interviewed 15 doctors for its article, and reports that none of them saw anything ethically wrong with the discount/rebate practice. Dr. Chynn noted that “It’s really not a conflict of interest,” because the discounts are relatively small.

About the Author

Barbara Gefvert | Editor-in-Chief, BioOptics World (2008-2020)

Barbara G. Gefvert has been a science and technology editor and writer since 1987, and served as editor in chief on multiple publications, including Sensors magazine for nearly a decade.

Sponsored Recommendations

Next generation tunable infrared lasers

Nov. 28, 2023
Discussion of more powerful and stable quantum cascade tunable infrared lasers, applications, and test results.

What AI demands mean for data centers

Nov. 28, 2023
The 2023 Photonics-Enabled Cloud Computing Summit assembled by Optica took an aggressive approach to calling out the limitations of today’s current technologies.

SLP feature for lighting control available on cameras offering

Nov. 28, 2023
A proprietary structured light projector (SLP) feature is now available on the company’s camera series, including the ace 2, boost R, ace U, and ace L.

Chroma Customer Spotlight - Dr. David Warshaw, About his Lab

Nov. 27, 2023
David Warshaw, Professor and Chair of Molecular Physiology and Biophysics at the University of Vermont (UVM), walks us through his lab. Learn about his lab’s work with the protein...

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Laser Focus World, create an account today!