With one lawsuit settled, another begins

Sept. 15, 2008
NASHUA, NH—The five-year battle between atomic force microscope (AFM) manufacturers Asylum Research Corporation (Santa Barbara, CA) and Veeco Instruments (based in Woodbury, N.Y. but with offices in Santa Barbara, CA) is over as of August 2008.

NASHUA, NH—The five-year battle between atomic force microscope (AFM) manufacturers Asylum Research Corporation (Santa Barbara, CA) and Veeco Instruments (based in Woodbury, N.Y. but with offices in Santa Barbara, CA) is over as of August 2008. The litigation began in September 2003, with Veeco Instruments alleging that Asylum’s MFP-3D AFM infringes on five patents owned by Veeco, in addition to other claims. Receiving news of the filing, Asylum immediately issued a statement denying that any Veeco patents are infringed in the manufacture of the MFP-3D, and adding that the company would vigorously defend itself—which it did over the years. Under the terms of the settlement, Asylum and Veeco have agreed to drop all pending claims against each other and agreed to a five-year, worldwide cross license of each other’s patents. They also made a mutual covenant not to sue on patents either party has a right to assert.

Asylum will pay an initial license fee to Veeco plus an ongoing royalty for the five-year term of the cross license. As part of the settlement, Asylum acknowledged the validity of the Veeco patents asserted in the case. Asylum CEO Jason Cleveland said the deal, “will allow both us and Veeco to bring better products to market.”

Meanwhile, National Laser Technology (NLT; Indianapolis, IN), a company that refurbishes and sells dental lasers to dentists in the U.S., has filed a lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana against Biolase Technology (Irvine, CA), which it says is damaging competition and affecting consumers in the hard-tissue dental-laser market. NLT is seeking compensatory and punitive damages, plus a preliminary and permanent injunction barring Biolase from engaging in anticompetitive conduct, making false and misleading statements, and retaliating.

The complaint alleges that Biolase, which reportedly has a market share of more than 85%, uses its competitive standing to coerce dentists to purchase products from Biolase at double the price offered by NLT. NLT alleges that as part of a campaign to put NLT out of business, Biolase threatens dentists by refusing to sell them laser tips and other necessary products if the dentists do business with NLT, and threatens to cut off trainers and other vendors who provide services to NLT customers. The complaint also asserts that Biolase has made false and misleading statements to dentists about NLT’s products.

“We have high-quality products to sell at low cost to compete with Biolase, but have been limited in our ability to provide these products to dentists because of the actions alleged in the complaint,” NLT CEO Alan Miller said. “We reluctantly brought this case because these actions have caused significant harm to NLT and to dentists.”

For its part, Biolase says that among other things, NLT sells used Biolase lasers—but is not an authorized Biolase dealer. “While NLT has yet to provide us with a copy of the complaint it filed against us, based on NLT’s press release … we believe that the allegations are frivolous and without merit. Biolase intends to defend the lawsuit vigorously, and will explore asserting appropriate claims against NLT,” said Biolase CEO Jake St. Philip. “We cannot guarantee the safety, effectiveness, or regulatory compliance of any used Biolase laser sold or modified by third-parties, and we will continue to work hard to protect dentists and patients, which is of the utmost importance to us.”

About the Author

Barbara Gefvert | Editor-in-Chief, BioOptics World (2008-2020)

Barbara G. Gefvert has been a science and technology editor and writer since 1987, and served as editor in chief on multiple publications, including Sensors magazine for nearly a decade.

Sponsored Recommendations

Request a free Micro 3D Printed sample part

April 11, 2024
The best way to understand the part quality we can achieve is by seeing it first-hand. Request a free 3D printed high-precision sample part.

Motion Scan and Data Collection Methods for Electro-Optic System Testing

April 10, 2024
Learn how different scanning patterns and approaches can be used in measuring an electro-optic sensor performance, by reading our whitepaper here!

Case Study: Medical Tube Laser Processing

March 28, 2024
To enhance their cardiovascular stent’s precision, optimize throughput and elevate part quality, a renowned manufacturer of medical products embarked on a mission to fabricate...

Melles Griot® XPLAN™ CCG Lens Series

March 19, 2024
IDEX Health & Science sets a new standard with our Melles Griot® XPLAN™ CCG Lens Series fluorescence microscope imaging systems. Access superior-quality optics with off-the-shelf...

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Laser Focus World, create an account today!