METAMATERIALS: Invisibility cloak without anisotropy doesn't quite do its job

Scientists at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) have determined that a recently popular approach to designing an invisibility cloak doesn't produce quite what was intended.1

While theory allows the design of optical invisibility cloaks that would perfectly hide things like cars, houses, and scientists from view, practical considerations make these designs virtually impossible to build. Such cloaks would be made from optical metamaterials, which are made up of structural components smaller than a wavelength of light, all of which must stay in alignment to each other to subwavelength-scale precision; for a cloak the size of a person, this would be an unattainable feat. In addition, large metamaterial cloaks would unavoidably absorb and scatter some of the light, defeating their purpose.

A perfectly reflecting mirror with a width of 4.0 units has a smooth bump 0.2 units high. An isotropic-metamaterial optical cloak 1.5 units high with a varying refractive index (color scale) is designed to perfectly hide the bump. For a light ray incoming at a 45° angle and striking near the top of the bump, the cloak successfully points the outgoing ray in the right direction, but fails at placing the outgoing ray at the proper exit point. (Courtesy of MIT)

Making things easier

So cloaking designers have simplified things in two ways. First, they are looking mainly at very small cloaks a few wavelengths in size; this makes the cloaks easier to build. Second, they are interested in certain special cases that allow them to make cloaks from simpler materials. Arbitrarily complex cloaking arrangements require the use of optically anisotropic metamaterials, which have the strange property that the phase front of the light traveling through it can be designed to be nonperpendicular to the direction of the light's travel. Anisotropic metamaterials are the most difficult to construct. In contrast, certain simplified cloaking arrangements may get by with the use of optically isotropic metamaterials instead, or even gradient-index dielectrics.

In one of these special cases, researchers give up on trying to hide an arbitrary object, and instead settle for trying to hide a bump on a perfectly reflecting mirror. The bump must be simple in shape, smoothly varying in height, and also with perfect reflectivity. The mirror and bump can then covered with a transparent isotropic cloaking layer that has a flat outer surface and a refractive index that varies in a way that, it is hoped, renders the bump invisible.

Seeing the result

What the MIT scientists have determined is that the jump from an anisotropic to an isotropic cloaking material comes at a cost. While an optically anisotropic material permits perfect cloaking of the mirror bump, a cloak made from an optically isotropic material only partially cloaks the bump: Although the phase fronts of a light beam reflected at an angle from the bump accurately mimic what would result if there were no bump, the light beam itself is laterally shifted (see figure). In one example consisting of a bump 0.2 units high cloaked with an isotropic gradient-index material (with refractive index varying between just under 1 to about 1.4), a ray reflected at an angle of 45° is shifted laterally by about 0.15 units—so the lateral shift of the angled ray is almost as great as the height of the bump being cloaked. (Because the refractive index dips just under 1, the cloak must still be made of metamaterial.)

So, to perfectly cloak a bump on a mirror, an optically anisotropic metamaterial remains a necessity, say the MIT researchers. As for more interesting cloaking devices that are designed to hide something other than a small reflective bump, there are the other obstacles as well, such as high absorbance, narrow transmission bands, and insufficient rigidity. Think of the articles in the general science and technology media that have played up the idea of a large-scale optical invisibility cloak with little or no explanation of the difficulties involved—and imagine how many people might think a supple (perhaps machine-washable) invisibility cape is, as a result, just around the corner.—John Wallace


  1. B. Zhang et al.,, Apr. 15, 2010.


More Laser Focus World Current Issue Articles
More Laser Focus World Archives Issue Articles

Get All the Laser Focus World News Delivered to Your Inbox

Subscribe to Laser Focus World Magazine or email newsletter today at no cost and receive the latest news and information.

 Subscribe Now

Most Popular Articles


Understanding Polarization and Optical Coatings

Light is an electromagnetic wave, but, at optical frequencies, it is its electric field that interacts with materials, with the direction of the electric fie...

Wave Optics Simulations

An add-on to COMSOL Multiphysics®, the Wave Optics Module offers capabilities for modeling optical phenomena. The innovative beam envelope method is among th...

Lens Design – Tools for designing manufacturable aspheres for complex optical assemblies

Designing aspheres that may be successfully fabricated and tested can be a frustrating experience. The range of possible aspheres is much larger than the ran...

Ray Optics Simulations with COMSOL Multiphysics

The Ray Optics Module can be used to simulate electromagnetic wave propagation when the wavelength is much smaller than the smallest geometric entity in the ...
White Papers

High-Power Diode Lasers under External Optical Feedback

We carried out a comprehensive study on single emitters with different antireflection (AR) coatin...

LED Reflector and Lens Simulation using TracePro® Illumination Design and Analysis Software

TracePro® allows users to design, analyze, and optimize LED lighting systems using software simul...

Degradation studies of a VECSEL gain structure using a stable green pump laser

The degradation of the gain structure of a red-emitting Optically Pumped Semiconductor (OPS) Vert...
Technical Digests

Fiber for Fiber Lasers

The development of higher-power and higher-energy fiber lasers has benefited from many advances i...

Click here to have your products listed in the Laser Focus World Buyers Guide.


Synopsys' CODE V Version 10.4 is now generally available

03/30/2012 Synopsys' CODE V Enhances Analysis of Precision Optical Systems.

Scratch-resistant mirror with gold surface

03/12/2012 In the LINOS catalog from Qioptiq you will now find the scratch-resistant mirror with gold surface.
Social Activity
Copyright © 2007-2014. PennWell Corporation, Tulsa, OK. All Rights Reserved. PRIVACY POLICY | TERMS AND CONDITIONS