PHOTONIC FRONTIERS: METAMATERIALS AND TRANSFORMATION OPTICS: Newest metamaterials promise customized optical properties

Tailoring the internal structure of metamaterials to vary optical properties controls how they transform light—leading to applications from optical cloaking to the optical counterparts of black holes

Jeff Hecht contributing editor

Click here to enlarge image

One of the hottest fields in optical research is undergoing an exciting transformation. Metamaterials research has given birth to a new field called transformation optics that promises to greatly extend the potential of assembling synthetic optical materials from subwavelength structures.

The first generation of metamaterials was built from identical and uniformly spaced subwavelength structures. Interactions of the electric and magnetic fields of light waves with the subwavelength modules produced effects that are impossible in natural materials, such as negative refractive indices. Their development offered the exciting potential to design entirely new types of optical materials.

Now developers have extended the concept to transformation optics, in which the modules and/or the spacing are not uniform throughout the material. Tailoring the complex nanostructure transforms the wavefront passing through it, enabling entirely new operations such as optical cloaking. The new field of transformation optics is “a new paradigm for the science of light,” says Vladimir Shalaev of Purdue University (West Lafayette, IN).

Metamaterial basics

Metamaterials were first demonstrated for microwaves, and extended to visible light by nanofabrication technology. Their optical properties are shaped by the interactions of arrays of subwavelength structures with the electric and magnetic fields that make up light waves (see Fig. 1). Because their internal structures differ from conventional materials, their optical properties can be very different.

FIGURE 1. Split-ring resonators are shown arranged in a uniformly spaced array in a negative-index metamaterial for microwave frequencies. Optical metamaterials use nanometer-scale elements. (Courtesy of Australian National University, Canberra)
Click here to enlarge image

The demonstration of negative refractive index was the real eye-opener. Optical engineers normally think of refractive index n as the ratio of the speed of light in vacuum to that in a material, but the underlying physics means the index actually is the square root of the product of electrical permittivity e and magnetic permeability µ.

Click here to enlarge image

Both quantities are defined as 1 in a vacuum, so n = 1 for vacuum.

Dielectrics such as glass have positive permittivity and permeability, so their refractive indices are positive. Conductors have negative permittivity and positive permeability at visible wavelengths, so these opaque materials have imaginary refractive indices. No natural materials have negative values of both quantities, but a decade ago John Pendry of Imperial College (London, England) showed that metamaterials could be made with both permittivity and permeability negative at selected wavelengths.

Since then negative-index superlenses have been demonstrated at optical wavelengths. The first used only single layers of modules, but last year Jason Valentine and Xiang Zhang at the University of California (Berkeley, CA) stacked layers to make the first three-dimensional metamaterials.1 But that was only a starting point.

Transformation optics and cloaking

Negative-index metamaterials are uniform, containing many identical and evenly spaced modules, so their optical properties are uniform as well. Changing the shape and spacing of internal structures within a metamaterial in an arbitrary way opens the door to transforming light in other ways. It’s a very powerful concept. Citing the late Arthur C. Clarke’s observation that, “any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic,” Ulf Leonhardt at the University of St. Andrews (St. Andrews, Scotland) and David R. Smith of Duke University (Durham, NC) wrote last year that transformation optics were “the first practical demonstrations of ‘pure and applied magic.’ ”2

The specific bit of magic that caught their eyes, and those of the popular press, is invisibility cloaking by deflecting light around an object in the middle of an area so the wavefront that reaches an observer seems to have come straight through the cloaked object, as if it wasn’t there (see Fig. 2). Like negative-index materials, cloaking was first seen for microwaves and then demonstrated for light.

Transformation optics determines how the properties of the cloak should vary through the metamaterial to deflect light away from the object. Early demonstrations used metamaterials assembled from conductive modules, but these have important drawbacks. The conductive elements strongly attenuate light, and their properties depend on resonance effects, which vary strongly with wavelength—meaning that they lose a lot of light and work only across a limited spectral range.

FIGURE 2. Optical cloaking hides an object by diverting light waves around it. A viewer at either side would be unaware that anything was in the cloaked zone.
Click here to enlarge image

Broadband cloaking is possible in other cases. This spring, two groups described broadband “carpet cloaks” that could hide a bump under a rug. Optically, previous cloak designs compress the hidden object into a single point or line from the viewer’s standpoint, wrote Valentine, Jensen Li, and Thomas Zentgraf of Zhang’s group at Berkeley, but “the carpet cloak compresses an object in only one direction into a conducting sheet.”3 That change in the shape of the wavefront doesn’t require singularities or drastic changes in properties through the material, allowing them to avoid resonance and use low-loss dielectric materials to achieve much broader bandwidth than is possible with conductors.

Valentine and colleagues drilled an array of 110 nm holes into a 250-nm-thick silicon slab optical waveguide. The researchers spaced the holes regularly except in a rectangular cloaking region, where the holes were arranged in a two-dimensional pattern designed to cloak a bump on the edge of the slab waveguide (see Fig. 3). When they directed a laser beam at a bump “under” the cloak, they saw a single Gaussian peak in the reflected light, as they would from a flat edge. Illuminating an uncloaked bump revealed multiple peaks, as expected for reflections from a bump. They observed the cloaking effect from 1400 to 1800 nm.

FIGURE 3. The optical dielectric cloak developed at Berkeley (shown here in a schematic) was formed by etching holes in a silicon layer. Holes are uniformly spaced in the waveguide layer, but arranged to produce a gradient-index cloak at the edge. Light directed through the planar waveguide and into the cloak does not “see” the bump at lower left; it is reflected as if the edge were straight. (Courtesy Xiang Zhang/UC Berkeley)
Click here to enlarge image

Lucas Gabrielli and colleges in Michal Lipson’s group at Cornell University (Ithaca, NY) demonstrated a similar dielectric carpet cloak, in which 50 nm silicon posts were embedded in a silica layer. Distribution of the silicon posts determined the optical transformation of the wavefront. The group also reported that its cloak concealed a bump on the edge of the planar waveguide across a 400 nm range in the 1550 nm region. Without the cloak, light reflected from the bump at an angle included a dark shadow-like zone, but with the cloak light reflection from the bump area was as smooth as if the area had been flat.4

Optical black holes

The power of transformation optics comes from the ability of a nonuniform metamaterial to warp the path of light arbitrarily, like a gravitational field can warp space-time. Zhang is working to extend the analogy so light propagation through metamaterials can be used in laboratory studies of such cosmic phenomena as black holes and strange attractors in the laboratory.

Zhang envisions devices he calls “continuous-index photon traps,” which could serve as “perfect” optical cavities that absorb light but don’t radiate across a broad range of wavelengths. One possibility is to combine air and the high-index semiconductor indium gallium arsenide phosphide (InGaAsP) to form a “photonic black hole,” which would attract light in the same way a gravitational black hole attracts matter.5 Zhang says transformation optics could design devices “that can mimic the periodic, quasi-periodic, and chaotic motions observed in celestial objects that have been subjected to complex gravitational fields” (see Fig. 4). One use could be to simulate the chaotic long-term orbits of planets and asteroids. “Unlike astronomers, we will not have to wait 100 years to get experimental results,” Zhang says.

Separately and nearly simultaneously, Evgenii E. Narimanova and Alexander V. Kildishev of Purdue proposed using transformation optics to make omnidirectional broadband light absorbers, or “optical black holes.” But they weren’t thinking of research applications. They envision practical applications including photovoltaics, solar-energy harvesting, and optoelectronic detectors.6

FIGURE 4. In an optical analog of a black hole, light spirals inward through an air-InGaAsP metamaterial structure. (Courtesy of Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory)
Click here to enlarge image

A similarly intriguing application of metamaterials is an omnidirectional retroreflector, recently demonstrated with microwaves by Leonhardt’s group. Like conventional retroreflectors made of multiple mirrors, the devices would reflect all incident light back in the direction from which it came, not just the ray incident on a reflective sphere at a right angle. With conventional optics, such a device would require a dielectric singularity with an infinite refractive index, but Leonhardt’s group used transformational optics to convert that singularity into a mere topological defect in a metamaterial.7

State of a fast-moving art

Although the idea of transformation optics has been around a while, key experiments have been reported within the past few months. As this article was about to go to press, Science published the first report of frequency-tunable “memory metamaterials,” in which frequency response can be both tuned and preserved.8 The tuning, demonstrated in Dimitri Basov’s lab at the University of California at San Diego (La Jolla, CA), is based on hysteresis in vanadium oxide structures in the metamaterial, and could lead to many other devices.

With transformation optics, says Shalaev, “you are limited only by your imagination because you really can do anything with light.” His excitement at his group’s recent demonstration of visible cloaking an area 100 wavelengths wide illustrates the state of the field.9 That’s only 50 µm, the width of a human hair, and a long way from hiding Harry Potter or even a covert microphone. But it’s an important step toward a bright future, and could lead even further. “You could make a cloak for light, you could make a cloak for electron wave functions, and you could make electron black holes,” he predicts. Stay tuned.


  1. J. Valentine et al., Nature 455, p. 376 (Sept. 18, 2008) doi:10.1038/nature07247
  2. U. Leonhardt and D. R. Smith, 2008 Focus on Cloaking and Transformation Optics New J. Phys. 10, p. 115019; doi: 10.1088/1367-2630/10/11/115019
  3. J. Valentine et al., Nature Materials (2009) doi:10.1038/nmat2461
  4. L. Gabrielli et al., Nature Photonics 3, p. 461 (Aug. 2009) doi:10.1038/nphoton.2009.117
  5. D. Genov et al., Nature Physics (July 20, 2009) (doi:10.1038/Nphys1338)
  6. E. E. Narimanova and Alexander V. Kildishev, Applied Phys. Lett. 95, 041106 (2009).
  7. Y. G. Ma et al., Nature Materials 28 (June 2009) doi:10:1038/nmat2489
  8. T. Driscoll et al., ScienceExpress 20 (August 2009) (doi:10.1126/science.11765580)
  9. I. Smolyaninov et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 213901 (May 29, 2009).

Tell us what you think about this article. Send an e-mail to

Most Popular Articles


Ray Optics Simulations with COMSOL Multiphysics

The Ray Optics Module can be used to simulate electromagnetic wave propagation when the wavelength is much smaller than the smallest geometric entity in the ...
White Papers

All About Aspheric Lenses

The most notable benefit of aspheric lenses is their ability to correct for spherical aberration....

Wavelength stabilized multi-kW diode laser systems

Wavelength stabilization of high-power diode laser systems is an important means to increase the ...

Accurate LED Source Modeling Using TracePro

Modern optical modeling programs allow product design engineers to create, analyze, and optimize ...
Technical Digests

OPTICAL COATINGS: Evolving technology produces new benefits

The antireflection, high-reflection, and/or spectral characteristics provided by optical coatings...

REMOTE FIBER-OPTIC SENSING: Data in abundance from difficult environments

The use of optical fibers to measure strain, temperature, and other parameters at desired points ...

SCANNERS FOR MATERIALS PROCESSING: Serving demanding applications

Galvanometer-based scanners are an essential component in laser-based materials-processing system...

Click here to have your products listed in the Laser Focus World Buyers Guide.


Synopsys' CODE V Version 10.4 is now generally available

03/30/2012 Synopsys' CODE V Enhances Analysis of Precision Optical Systems.

Scratch-resistant mirror with gold surface

03/12/2012 In the LINOS catalog from Qioptiq you will now find the scratch-resistant mirror with gold surface.
Social Activity
Copyright © 2007-2014. PennWell Corporation, Tulsa, OK. All Rights Reserved.PRIVACY POLICY | TERMS AND CONDITIONS