Recent announcement by NASA of nanotube ultrablack absorber is predated by other work, says independent researcher

Ashland, MA--A carbon-nanotube (CNT)-based optical absorber that absorbs 98% to 99.5% of incident radiation within the UV to far-IR band, unveiled by NASA in November, 2011, is not actually the first of its kind, according to Robert Crowley, president of Soundwave Research Laboratories. On Soundwave's blog site, Crowley notes that the NASA absorber is similar to a CNT ultrablack surface that Crowley himself invented and received several patents on, including one with a priority date of January 16, 1997.

NASA's absorber consists of a forest of vertical CNTs grown on a substrate such as silicon, silicon nitride, titanium, or stainless steel, creating an almost perfect blackbody absorber or emitter over a large wavelength range. Astronomy and spacecraft optical sytems are just two of the applications for the coating.

Crowley's 1997 patent contains the claim: "An electromagnetic energy absorbing structure device comprising: a substrate for supporting an aligned array of electromagnetic energy modifying nanotubes thereon; an array of nanotubes on said substrate arranged for the receipt of electromagnetic energy, wherein the electromagnetic energy received by the nanotubes arranged on the substrate is selected from the group consisting of: electromagnetic energy in the visible range, electromagnetic energy in the ultraviolet range or electromagnetic energy in the infrared range."

In his blog, Crowley mentions the use of his ultrablack surface for solar thermal absorbers, as well as for coating the insides of optical systems to get rid of internal reflections. In a private communication, he notes that he and his colleagues offered the absorber to ARPA-E, as the technology is a "game-changer in solar thermal applications."

"We do not begrudge our colleagues who still only rely on scientific papers for their research, but respectfully suggest that if they want to know what preceded, they should also be citing patents," says Crowley. "Forward-thinking academics are coming around to the idea that patents are at least as well peer-reviewed as some journal articles, and also stand the test of novelty, utility, and nonobviousness."

Get All the Laser Focus World News Delivered to Your Inbox

Subscribe to Laser Focus World Magazine or email newsletter today at no cost and receive the latest news and information.

 Subscribe Now

Most Popular Articles


Understanding Polarization and Optical Coatings

Light is an electromagnetic wave, but, at optical frequencies, it is its electric field that interacts with materials, with the direction of the electric fie...

Wave Optics Simulations

An add-on to COMSOL Multiphysics®, the Wave Optics Module offers capabilities for modeling optical phenomena. The innovative beam envelope method is among th...

Lens Design – Tools for designing manufacturable aspheres for complex optical assemblies

Designing aspheres that may be successfully fabricated and tested can be a frustrating experience. The range of possible aspheres is much larger than the ran...

Ray Optics Simulations with COMSOL Multiphysics

The Ray Optics Module can be used to simulate electromagnetic wave propagation when the wavelength is much smaller than the smallest geometric entity in the ...
White Papers

Degradation studies of a VECSEL gain structure using a stable green pump laser

The degradation of the gain structure of a red-emitting Optically Pumped Semiconductor (OPS) Vert...

All About Aspheric Lenses

The most notable benefit of aspheric lenses is their ability to correct for spherical aberration....

Accurate LED Source Modeling Using TracePro

Modern optical modeling programs allow product design engineers to create, analyze, and optimize ...
Technical Digests

Fiber for Fiber Lasers

The development of higher-power and higher-energy fiber lasers has benefited from many advances i...

Click here to have your products listed in the Laser Focus World Buyers Guide.


Synopsys' CODE V Version 10.4 is now generally available

03/30/2012 Synopsys' CODE V Enhances Analysis of Precision Optical Systems.

Scratch-resistant mirror with gold surface

03/12/2012 In the LINOS catalog from Qioptiq you will now find the scratch-resistant mirror with gold surface.
Social Activity
Copyright © 2007-2014. PennWell Corporation, Tulsa, OK. All Rights Reserved. PRIVACY POLICY | TERMS AND CONDITIONS